You probably heard the news that Boardwalk REIT (TSE:BEI.UN) is reducing distributions from $2.25 to $1.00.
It is over 55% reduction.
I have 125 units of BEI.UN in my Canadian investment portfolio. Thus, it cost my yearly passive income by $156.25.
Ouch!
But, when I compare to my overall passive income, cut is just less than 2%.
This is not the first time I am experiencing a distribution cut. During the oil crash, three of my holdings (CVE, COS and KMI) reduced their dividends payments.
Later, I sold CVE and COS and recorded lost and continue holding KMI. At the same time, I purchased SU in high 20s and later sold it in low 40s. All balanced out well.
Recently, General Electric (GE) was in my portfolio, but I sold it before its dividend cut and redeployed the capital to purchase another stock.
If you notice carefully, there are some connections in my dividend cutters. All of the stocks (except GE) are somehow related to OIL.
Boardwalk REIT (TSE: BEI.UN) is one of Canada’s largest owner or operator of multi-family rental communities and it owns and operates over 220 properties with around 34 000 rental units.
BEI.UN is primarily focused on Alberta and Saskatchewan, and these two provinces hit hard by oil downturn, so does this REIT.
The distribution cut was not surprising, given the fact that the REIT had a high payout ratio amidst a down trend in FFO per unit.
BEI.UN was almost paying 100% of its Fund from Operation (FFO). Thus, it was struggling to handle its renovation expenses and growth projects.
After the reduction, the payout ratio will be around 60% (distribution / FFO), which is more sustainable.
What I am going to do with my BEI.UN units?
At this moment, I am not going to make any changes. In my view, management made a right decision to reduce distribution and believe that the revised payout ratio will provide flexibility to focus on the units’ renovations and geographic diversification of the portfolio.
In Q3/17 report, management has unveiled a strategy to reduce Alberta & Saskatchewan exposure to 50% and focus to other high growth locations like GTA, Vancouver, Ottawa, Montreal, etc.
Distribution reductions will help the trust to grow and diversify its portfolio at low cost of capital, instead of digging deep into debt.
I continue believe in the management team. They’ve done a great job in the past. Therefore, I continue hold the BEI.UN units in my portfolio. I may consider adding few more units if its price drop below $30.
According to Q3/17 report, Net Asset Value (NAV) of the trust unit value is $62.71. Therefore, average value of its apartment is around $170K.
If I sell my holding now, it is like selling $170K worth of apartment unit for $135K.
Mainly investors own REITs for income purpose. Reduction is little hard to take for those solo rely on these income.
Diversification is the key minimize the impact from these types of scenarios.
Like many investors, I was lazy enough to buy rental properties and handle all the landlord duties. Instead, I purchased these REITs and collect my monthly rents.
Let’s say I have two apartment units. One tenant refused to pay my rent, damage my apartment unit and left. It is like 50% reduction in my rental income (aka distribution cut) and some cost for renovation (aka price drop). All I can do is accept the fact and take 50% cut until find a new tenant.
I am in similar situation with Boardwalk REIT. Instead of two units, I have so many units and the reduction is less than 2% of my overall passive income. And, no need to do the renovations works and look for new tenants.
All I need to do is just sit back and monitor the situation.
From my previous experience, I expect that BEI.UN may experience a selling pressure for sometimes. This may give a tiny downward pressure in my overall portfolio value. As a long-term investor, I am ready to take risk and handle these types short-term shocks.
Please note the information posted on this website is the opinion of my own and should not be considered as professional financial advice. I am not a financial professional, and I can buy, sell, or hold any investment at anytime.
Any transactions I publish on this website are not recommendations to buy or sell any securities or investments.
Please do your own research or consult with a qualified financial professional before even considering using the information obtained from this website.
Thibault Albert says
Hi
I thought REITs are much safer than other dividend payers, but I disappointed with this.
What is your thought about Enbridge? One of the big holdings in your portfolio.
Finance Jouneny says
Hello Thibault,
Thank you for stopping by,
I had a similar opinion with REITs, especially with apartment REITs, but BEI.UN had changed my opinion. I learnt the lesson, and will be careful in the future.
Regarding ENB- ENB is 3rd or 4th largest holding in my portfolio. Dividend cut will be a minor disaster for me. I really hope the dividend is safe at this moment, but nobody can predict the future.
I am still trying to understand the reason behind the sell-off. There might some issues that retails investors can’t understand.
Best Regards,
Mark K says
I have fairly large position in BEI.UN, I am thinking sell a half position and buy CAR.UN. Your opinion?
Thanks
Finance Jouneny says
Hello Mark,
Thank you for stopping by,
I am sorry! I can’t give you my opinion without knowing about your financial situation and risk tolerance. I am just sharing my journey on this website, I would recommend you to do more research or discuss with a qualified financial adviser before make any financial decisions.
Best Regards,
Passivecanadianincome says
Great writeup. Like you i am a shareholder. I sold my position in our resp at break even price. I will either buy more when it drops dramatically or buy a railroad for the resp. My tfsa boardwalk is down 8% ill keep that. Like you said long term its a good move.
Cheers
Finance Jouneny says
Hello Passive Canadian Income,
Thank you for stopping by,
I am still underwater by around $300 with BEI.UN, I hope things get improved in the coming years.
Cheers,
Trappin says
That NAV estimate is pure fiction.
See my two articles on seeking alpha for a detailed explanation.
Finance Jouneny says
Hello Trappin,
Companies (REITs) always give a bit high NAV estimate for their properties. Therefore, it could be bit low than $62/unit, but it doesn’t low as current trading value of less than $40.
All of them are apartment units, so they always have some value in any economic situations (I hope).
Best Regards,
Trappin says
NO. In this case it is pure fantasy. The NOI they are using to justify this is incredible removed from reality.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4125200-reit-will-cut-dividend-part-2
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4098645-reit-will-cut-dividend
Finance Jouneny says
Hello Trappin,
Thank you for sharing the URL and your opinion. I will have a look at the details at SeekingAlpha.
Best Regards,
Eugene says
Hi there,
what do you thing about ENB? Shares are going slightly down but dividents no. Are you planning to sell anything or will keep?
Finance Jouneny says
Hello Eugene,
I am doing more analysis about ENB as it is one of my larger position in my portfolio, and will write a short post about it.
Best Regards,